Conducted by Elim Chan, the Netherlands Philharmonic Orchestra performs Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky’s Symphony No. 5 in E minor, Op. 64. This performance was recorded during the Sunday Morning Concert on January 19, 2020, in Het Concertgebouw in Amsterdam.
Tchaikovsky’s Symphony No. 5
Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky’s Symphony No. 5 in E minor, Op. 64, composed in 1888, is one of his most performed and beloved works. This symphony, written during a time of personal uncertainty and self-doubt for Tchaikovsky, reflects a profound emotional journey marked by struggle, hope, and ultimate triumph. Despite his initial reservations about his abilities as a symphonist, Tchaikovsky poured his soul into this composition, creating a work of deep emotional resonance and structural ingenuity.
The symphony is often interpreted as a narrative of fate and redemption, a theme Tchaikovsky had explored previously in his Fourth Symphony. Throughout the Fifth Symphony, a recurring “fate” motif acts as a unifying thread, appearing in various guises and transforming as the work progresses. This motif is first introduced by the clarinet in the symphony’s opening and reappears in different forms in each movement, lending a sense of cohesion and thematic continuity to the entire work.
Tchaikovsky’s orchestration in Symphony No. 5 is rich and imaginative, showcasing his mastery of the orchestra. He skillfully blends the timbres of different sections to create a wide range of colors and textures. The symphony features sweeping, lyrical melodies characteristic of Tchaikovsky’s style, along with dramatic contrasts and powerful climaxes that heighten the emotional impact. The lush strings, powerful brass, and delicate woodwinds all contribute to the symphony’s expressive depth.
One of the most striking aspects of this symphony is its emotional intensity. Tchaikovsky’s music often delves into the extremes of human feeling, from profound melancholy to exhilarating joy. This emotional breadth is evident throughout the symphony, making it a deeply moving and compelling listening experience. The work’s dramatic narrative and rich orchestral writing have made it a favorite among audiences and performers alike.
Symphony No. 5 was premiered in St. Petersburg on November 17, 1888, under Tchaikovsky’s own baton. Initially, it received mixed reviews, with some critics finding it overly emotional or even bombastic. However, over time, the symphony has come to be regarded as one of Tchaikovsky’s greatest achievements, praised for its emotional power, structural integrity, and masterful orchestration.
Movements
With the start times in the video above:
- 00:00 Andante-Allegro con anima
- 14:07 Andante cantabile, con alcuna licenza
- 26:45 Valse: Allegro moderato
- 32:30 Finale: Andante maestoso – Allegro vivace
1. Andante-Allegro con anima
The first movement of Tchaikovsky’s Symphony No. 5 is marked “Andante – Allegro con anima.” This movement sets the stage for the entire symphony, introducing themes and motifs that will reappear throughout the work, most notably the “fate” motif that is central to the symphony’s narrative.
The movement begins with a slow and solemn introduction (Andante), where the “fate” motif is introduced by the clarinet in a low, dark register. This motif, characterized by its descending line, immediately establishes a sense of foreboding and sets a contemplative mood. The orchestration is sparse, allowing the motif to stand out clearly and creating an atmosphere of introspection.
As the introduction progresses, the tension gradually builds, leading into the main body of the movement (Allegro con anima). The tempo increases, and the music becomes more animated and lively. The Allegro section introduces the first main theme, a restless and vigorous melody played by the strings and punctuated by the woodwinds and brass. This theme is energetic and driving, contrasting sharply with the somber opening.
Following the first theme, Tchaikovsky introduces a contrasting second theme, which is more lyrical and flowing. This theme, played by the clarinet and later taken up by the strings, provides a sense of warmth and hope amidst the movement’s overall dramatic tension. The interplay between the two themes creates a dynamic and engaging musical narrative.
The development section of the movement is marked by its complexity and dramatic intensity. Tchaikovsky explores and manipulates the thematic material, taking it through various keys and developing it in new and inventive ways. The “fate” motif reappears, sometimes subtly woven into the texture, other times more prominently, reinforcing its significance in the symphony’s narrative.
As the development reaches its climax, the music becomes increasingly turbulent, with powerful brass and driving rhythms creating a sense of urgency. This leads into the recapitulation, where the main themes return, now more forcefully and with heightened emotional intensity. The contrast between the vigorous first theme and the lyrical second theme is even more pronounced, highlighting Tchaikovsky’s skill in thematic development and orchestration.
The movement concludes with a coda that draws on the “fate” motif and the main themes, bringing the movement to a powerful and dramatic close. The final passages are marked by their intensity and emotional weight, leaving the listener with a sense of anticipation for the movements to come.
2. Andante cantabile, con alcuna licenza
The second movement of Tchaikovsky’s Symphony No. 5 is marked “Andante cantabile, con alcuna licenza.” This movement is renowned for its lyrical beauty and emotional depth, standing in contrast to the dramatic intensity of the first movement.
The movement begins with a serene and heartfelt horn solo, introducing the main theme that is characterized by its lyrical and cantabile (singing) quality. This theme, supported by a gentle string accompaniment, sets a mood of introspective calm and tender emotion. The melody is one of Tchaikovsky’s most beautiful and memorable, imbued with a sense of longing and nostalgia.
As the theme develops, the orchestration becomes richer, with the strings taking up the melody and the woodwinds providing delicate counterpoints. The interplay between the different sections of the orchestra highlights Tchaikovsky’s mastery of orchestration, creating a lush and expressive soundscape.
The middle section of the movement introduces a contrasting theme that is more agitated and dramatic. This section is marked by dynamic contrasts and rhythmic complexity, providing a sense of tension and conflict. The passionate outbursts of the brass and the swirling strings add to the movement’s emotional intensity, creating a powerful contrast to the serene opening theme.
Throughout the movement, Tchaikovsky skillfully interweaves the lyrical and dramatic elements, maintaining a delicate balance between the two. The “fate” motif from the first movement makes a subtle reappearance, reminding the listener of the underlying narrative of the symphony. This motif is woven into the fabric of the music, adding to the movement’s emotional complexity.
The recapitulation brings back the main theme, now with even greater warmth and expressiveness. The return of the serene melody, played by the strings and supported by the full orchestra, creates a sense of resolution and calm. The movement concludes with a gentle coda, where the main theme is restated in a peaceful and contemplative manner, gradually fading into silence.
3. Valse: Allegro moderato
The third movement of Tchaikovsky’s Symphony No. 5 is marked “Valse: Allegro moderato.” This movement serves as a graceful and elegant interlude, offering a lighter and more dance-like contrast to the intense and emotional first two movements.
The “Valse” (waltz) form is central to this movement, and Tchaikovsky masterfully employs it to create a flowing and lyrical piece that is both charming and sophisticated. The movement opens with a lilting waltz theme played by the strings, immediately establishing a sense of rhythmic elegance and grace. The melody is light and airy, characterized by its triple meter and a flowing, dance-like quality.
As the movement progresses, the main theme is taken up by various sections of the orchestra, each adding its own color and texture to the music. The woodwinds, in particular, contribute to the movement’s lightness and charm with their playful and delicate interjections. Tchaikovsky’s orchestration is skillful and imaginative, with the different instrumental timbres blending seamlessly to create a rich and varied sonic palette.
The middle section of the movement introduces a contrasting theme that is more lyrical and expansive. This theme is marked by its flowing melody and gentle, pastoral character, providing a moment of calm and introspection within the overall dance-like framework. The interplay between the contrasting themes adds depth and complexity to the movement, showcasing Tchaikovsky’s ability to weave together different musical ideas in a cohesive and engaging manner.
Throughout the “Valse,” Tchaikovsky maintains a delicate balance between lightness and sophistication, with the music never losing its sense of elegance and poise. The movement is marked by its dynamic contrasts and subtle shifts in tempo and mood, creating a sense of forward momentum and keeping the listener engaged.
The recapitulation brings back the main waltz theme, now with even greater charm and vitality. The movement concludes with a graceful coda, where the main theme is restated in a more subdued and reflective manner, gradually fading into a gentle and elegant ending. This conclusion provides a sense of closure and prepares the listener for the dramatic final movement of the symphony.
4. Finale: Andante maestoso – Allegro vivace
The fourth movement of Tchaikovsky’s Symphony No. 5 is marked “Andante maestoso – Allegro vivace.” This movement serves as a powerful and triumphant conclusion to the symphony, bringing together the themes and motifs introduced in the earlier movements and culminating in a grand and victorious finale.
The movement opens with a majestic introduction (Andante maestoso) that recalls the “fate” motif introduced in the first movement. This motif, now presented in a transformed and more triumphant character, is played by the brass and sets a tone of solemn grandeur. The motif undergoes several variations, creating a sense of anticipation and preparation for the energetic Allegro vivace that follows.
As the tempo increases to Allegro vivace, the main theme of the movement bursts forth with a sense of exuberance and vitality. This theme is characterized by its rhythmic drive and energetic character, with the strings leading the way in a lively and spirited dance. The woodwinds and brass provide dynamic support, adding to the movement’s overall sense of joy and celebration.
The second theme of the Allegro vivace is more lyrical and flowing, offering a contrast to the driving main theme. This theme is introduced by the woodwinds and then taken up by the strings, creating a beautiful and expansive melodic line. The interplay between the two themes adds depth and complexity to the movement, with Tchaikovsky skillfully balancing the energetic and lyrical elements.
The development section of the movement is marked by its dramatic intensity and inventive treatment of the thematic material. Tchaikovsky explores and elaborates on the main themes, taking them through various keys and dynamic contrasts. The music builds to a powerful climax, with the “fate” motif reappearing in a more forceful and assertive form.
In the recapitulation, the main themes return with even greater intensity and grandeur. The music gains momentum as it drives towards the final climax, with the full orchestra playing at its most powerful. The “fate” motif, now fully transformed into a symbol of triumph and victory, is prominently featured, creating a sense of resolution and fulfillment.
The movement concludes with a rousing coda, where the main themes are brought together in a final, exhilarating statement. The brass and percussion add to the sense of triumph, and the symphony ends with a series of emphatic chords that leave the listener with a feeling of exhilaration and satisfaction.
Sources
- Symphony No. 5 (Tchaikovsky) on Wikipedia
- Tchaikovsky – Symphony No. 5 in E minor on Classic FM website
- Symphony No. 5 on the Tchaikovsky Research website
- César Franck: Violin Sonata [Argerich, Capuçon] - September 8, 2024
- Beethoven: Piano Sonata No. 23 “Appassionata” [Anna Fedorova] - September 7, 2024
- Telemann: Concerto for Recorder and Viola da Gamba [Barrocada] - September 3, 2024